An actual fucking X
Overall, I like situated criticism - the idea that being a part of X group gives you a lived experience inaccessible to those outside X, and makes you more qualified to speak on X than someone who doesn't know anything about it. I think it's a good thing. I think historically lived experience has been discredited as subjective and thus not worthy of attention. However, I don't like certain ways it's used. Namely, I really, really do not like the fact that it can make someone into a token. For example, let's say that I'm the only woman in a room full of men (a really common situation for me, because of my area of study). Let's also say that I'm the only woman in a room full of men talking about feminism (this has happened). At some point, one of them will get nervous and ask "as a woman, what do you think?". As a woman, here's what I think: Think for yourselves. You're grown adults. You can deal with criticism from another grown